PRB: DdeInitialize Fails in Implicitly-Loaded DLL's LibMain() (94954)

SYMPTOMS

When implementing DDEML from an implicitly-loaded dynamic-link library (DLL), calling DdeInitialize() from the DLL's LibMain() function causes the DdeInitialize() call to fail (that is, results to an exception 13). Moving the call to DdeInitialize() anywhere other than LibMain() corrects the problem.

CAUSE

In DdeInitialize(), DDEML initializes its data structures, allocates memory, and also creates windows (for its own internal use). This, of course, causes messages to be sent to the application's message queue, which at LibMain() time, in an implicitly-loaded DLL, does not exist yet. These messages sent to a non-existent message queue result to an exception 13.

RESOLUTION

One way to resolve this problem is to export another function in the DLL, call it InitDDEML(), which can call DdeInitialize() and perform all necessary initializations. This guarantees that when the function InitDDEML() is called, the application's message queue has been properly initialized.

Another way to resolve this problem is to keep the DdeInitialize() call in LibMain(), but to explicitly load the DLL via LoadLibrary(). This also ensures that the calling application's message queue exists before the call to DdeInitialize() in LibMain().

MORE INFORMATION

Because an implicitly-loaded DLL is loaded into memory before the calling application is completely loaded, LibMain(), [which is analogous to an application's WinMain()] is called before the application's message queue is initialized. As a result, the DLL must not call functions that send messages to the application in LibMain().

This problem is not specific to DDEML.

Similarly, an implicitly-loaded DLL is terminated after the calling application has been removed from memory. Therefore, nothing in the Windows exit procedure (WEP) must require the application to exist.