FIX: Subtracting Two Externs Gives Incorrect Results (75177)

The information in this article applies to:

Microsoft Macro Assembler (MASM) 6.0

This article was previously published under Q75177

SYMPTOMS

Subtracting two external variables in the Microsoft Macro Assembler (MASM) version 6.0 results in an incorrect value, and the assembler does not generate any errors. It should produce an error similar to the one received in MASM 5.1, such as:

A2032: Illegal Use of extern

CAUSE

When subtracting two local variables, the assembler will correctly calculate the difference in their offsets. However, with external variables, it does not know the offset at assemble time, so it cannot correctly determine their difference.

RESOLUTION

The difference in offsets for external variables can be calculated by moving the values into registers or temporary variables and then performing the calculation. The sample code below illustrates this problem.

STATUS

Microsoft has confirmed this to be a problem in MASM version 6.0. This problem was corrected in MASM version 6.0a.

MORE INFORMATION

Sample Code 1

; Assemble options needed: none

.MODEL small
.STACK 4096

.DATA
extrn Var1 : byte, Var2 : byte ; The extern variables

.CODE
    .startup
    mov ax, offset Var1   ; Gives correct offset of extern var1
    mov bx, offset Var2   ; Gives correct offset of extern var2
    mov cx, (Var2 - Var1) ; Incorrectly calculate a zero for
                          ; the difference
    sub bx, ax            ; This will calculate the correct value
    .exit 0
END

Sample Code 2

; Contains the external variable definitions

PUBLIC   Var1, Var2
.MODEL small
.DATA
Var1     byte   '5'
Var2     byte   '9'
END

Modification Type:	Major	Last Reviewed:	10/20/2003
Keywords:	kbfix KB75177