BUG: ADO Recordset Clone Events Positioned to Incorrect Record (248678)

MORE INFORMATION

A Clone Recordset is a pointer to the same data as another Recordset, except that a Clone Recordset has an independent Bookmark. Therefore, the current position in the main Recordset and in the Clone can be different. A MoveNext in one does not affect the position of the other.

When you edit a record in one Recordset, the other may or may not be positioned on it. Event procedures, such as WillChangeField or FieldChangeComplete merely pass a pointer to the Recordset and the Fields collection. The events do not reposition the record.

When data is changed in one Recordset, the events in the other provide a Recordset which does not point to the record being affected.

Steps to Reproduce Behavior

1. In Visual Basic 5.0 or 6.0, open a new Standard EXE project.
2. From the Project menu select the References menu to add a reference to Microsoft ActiveX Data Objects.
3. Add a Command button (Command1) and the following code to the default form:

   Option Explicit
   
   Dim WithEvents rs As ADODB.Recordset
   Dim WithEvents rsClone As ADODB.Recordset
   
   Private Sub Form_Activate()
     Set rs = New ADODB.Recordset
     rs.Fields.Append "Col", adInteger
     rs.Open
     rs.AddNew "Col", 1
     rs.AddNew "Col", 2
     rs.AddNew "Col", 3
     rs.AddNew "Col", 4
     rs.AddNew "Col", 5
     Set rsClone = rs.Clone
     rs.MoveLast
     Debug.Print "Initial rs Record:", rs!Col
     Debug.Print "Initial rsClone Record:", rsClone!Col
   End Sub
   
   Private Sub Command1_Click()
     ' rsClone.Bookmark = rs.Bookmark
     rs!Col = 1000
     rs.Update
     Debug.Print "rs Record after edit:", rs!Col
     Debug.Print "rsClone Record after edit:", rsClone!Col
     rsClone.Bookmark = rs.Bookmark
     Debug.Print "Clone sync'd with rs:", rsClone!Col
   End Sub
   
   Private Sub rs_WillChangeField(ByVal cFields As Long, ByVal Fields As Variant, adStatus As ADODB.EventStatusEnum, _
                                  ByVal pRecordset As ADODB.Recordset)
     Debug.Print "rs WillChangeField:", pRecordset!Col
   End Sub
   
   Private Sub rsClone_WillChangeField(ByVal cFields As Long, ByVal Fields As Variant, adStatus As ADODB.EventStatusEnum, _
                                       ByVal pRecordset As ADODB.Recordset)
     Debug.Print "rsClone WillChangeField:", pRecordset!Col
   End Sub
   
   					

4. Run the application and click the command button. The output should appear as follows:

   Initial rs Record:           5 
   Initial rsClone Record:      1 
   rs WillChangeField:          5 
   rsClone WillChangeField:     1 
   rs Record after edit:        1000 
   rsClone Record after edit:   1 
   Clone sync'd with rs:        1000 
   						

   NOTE: The clone record position does not change. If it explicitly set to the record that was edited, it does show the changes.
5. Uncomment the first line of the Command1_Click procedure and run the application again. This time, the clone is positioned on the same record as the main Recordset prior to the edit. The results are as follows:

   >
   Initial rs Record:           5 
   Initial rsClone Record:      1   <-- clone is repositioned after this point
   rs WillChangeField:          5 
   rsClone WillChangeField:     5 
   rs Record after edit:        1000 
   rsClone Record after edit:   1000 
   Clone sync'd with rs:        1000 
   					

NOTE: The Fields argument of the cloned Recordset's event procedures also give the value of the fields in the cloned recordset's current position. Replacing the event Debug.Print statements with

  Debug.Print "rsClone WillChangeField:", Fields(0).Value
				

produces identical results as the existing code.